Posted by dingo in televisibility at 11:33 pm |
Permanent Link
A warning: I’m going to talk about the season finale of Lost, which means if you don’t watch Lost, there is absolutely reason you should read this post. Every word beyond this sentence will be a spoiler; consider yourself warned.
Still here? OK. I loved the season finale. Things happened, enormous things that were exciting and crazy and weird. I loved finding out what happens when you don’t press the button (I’m a sucker for electromagnetic white-light explosions), I loved where Locke’s character finally found himself (and what it hopefully means for season three), and I loved Desmond’s flashback, which was everything a great Lost flashback should be — revealing, surprising, mysterious, and poignant. The finale created more loose ends than it tied up, but there were no cop-outs in what was revealed, and I appreciate that greatly.
I also hated the season finale, because I now know that Michael is an irreedeemable ass, because I have to wait until October to find out what the fuck that four-toed statue is, and because I’m now quite scared we won’t find out what that four-toed statue is before I die in 2047. Anyone remember the robotic-dinosaur black-smoke security monster? Uh-huh. Do you think you could gently remind the writers?
After having been burned by The X-Files (a show I wrongly assumed had some sort of destination in mind) and American Gothic (which promised me much and then disappointed me greatly by getting itself cancelled), I’m more than a bit gunshy around popular American network television. I’m fairly convinced that Lost ultimately knows where it’s headed, but I’m also fairly convinced that ABC’s analysts have predicted there’s eight seasons’ worth of money to be made, so I will not get my wish of three seasons and done with it. To fall in love with a television show is dangerous, but it happened, and I’m more than a bit nervous about where our relationship is headed.
A few characters have already fallen victim to the s-t-r-e-t-c-h — Charlie, for example, meandered from helpful father figure to evil heroin addict to helpful father figure to obsessive stalker to helpful father figure, and I’m not sure what purpose those pitstops in Evilville served. Same goes for Sawyer: He’s bad. He’s actually a sweetheart. No, he’s really bad. Frog-squishing bad. No, he’s truly a softie. I’m all for three-dimensional characters, but I don’t sense these folks learning or growing from their trials and tribulations; they’re just visiting Jail and wandering back to Go. Locke had a similar roller-coaster arc this season, but I think (hope?) he may have actually changed because of his ordeal, so all is forgiven.
But I think the worst misstep the show made this season is the treatment of Libby and Shannon, two characters that were unceremoniously offed just as they were starting to get interesting. I suppose their offings would have been more acceptable if they didn’t serve exactly the same purpose. See if you can spot the similarities: Shannon and Sayid start falling in love, some jerk shoots her totally by accident, and Sayid has reason to brood and be vengeful. Libby and Hurley start falling in love, some jerk shoots her totally by accident, and Hurley has reason to brood and be vengeful. Even worse: They didn’t even have the decency to resolve Sayid’s post-girlfriend-death issues before saddling Hurley with the same ones. Blah. At least Hurley has the potential to turn into more than just the lovable fat guy as a result of all this.
But aside from these complaints (I tend to call out faults more than point out strengths, which can speak for themselves), I still think this is fantastic television, addictive and enthralling enough to warrant me writing a blog post. It helps fill the void as I wait for October, and October, and October, and October.

